Our reasons for becoming insurance professionals are deeply personal. We repeatedly saw friends and family struggling to find the coverage they needed. We are confident that with our understanding of the insurance space, we can help people better prepare for the future. After years in the business, we have developed a reputation for educating individuals in an easy-to-understand manner, so they can easily grasp personal insurance concepts. Above all else, we feel a commitment to our community.
Find an Insurance Professional
CEO / President
Scott J. Carey is the CEO/President of Carey Insurance Group and All American Mortgage. He began his career on June 13, 1992, by joining his father’s insurance agency. In 2002, Scott and his father opened All American Mortgage....
Account Executive / Loan Officer
Cell: 302-245-2327 Jim Fritz is an Associate for Carey Insurance Group and a loan officer for All American Mortgage (AAM). Jim specializes in life insurance, long-term care, reverse mortgages as well as personal lines insurance. Jim...
Robin Timmons is the Office Manager for Carey Insurance Group at the Dagsboro location. Robin joined Carey Insurance in 2000. Prior to Carey Insurance, she was employed by Insurance Unlimited and Gray Insurance totaling 40 years of...
Personal Lines Account Manager
Terri joined Carey Insurance Group in June 2019. She started her career as a Customer Service Representative and later moved into the position of Office Manager in our Dagsboro office. Prior to coming to Carey Insurance Group, Terri...
Michelle started her career with Carey Insurance Group in 2002 and works out of our Dagsboro, Delaware office. Michelle came to us with over 10 years of experience in the Customer Service in the Banking industry. She graduated from...
June joined Carey Insurance Group in 2014 and works out of our Dagsboro, Delaware office. She comes to us with over 13 years of experience in the Banking Industry. June is a graduate from Sussex Central High School. She loves the Beach...
Laura started her career with Carey Insurance Group in October 2020. She achieved her P&C Insurance License and is currently working out of our Dagsboro Office. Laura has been married for 16 years to Evan, her High School sweetheart....
Jennifer joined Carey Insurance Group in February 2020 as a Account Manager. Jennifer is originally from Baltimore, MD. Jennifer graduated from Our Lady of Mt. Carmel HS and TSU with a Degree in Mental Health / Psychology. Prior to...
Personal Lines Rater
Susan started her career with Carey Insurance Group in November 2020. With over 34 years experience in the Insurance industry. Susan holds the position of Personal Lines Rater in our Dagsboro office. Susan graduated from James M...
Travis graduated from Marist College in May 2004 with his Degree in Finance. He started his career with Carey Insurance Group just a month after graduation in our All American Mortgage division. Travis was added to our Insurance...
All American Mortgage
Billy is a Loan Officer for All American Mortgage (AAM), specializing in residential home lending. Prior to joining AAM in 2004, Billy was a farmer in Lower Sussex County, Delaware. In 1978, Billy earned his Associates Degree in...
Office Manager / Account Executive
Hope joined Carey Insurance Group in 2019. She comes to us with 30 years experience in the Insurance industry. She is licensed in Delaware and Maryland and specializes in personal lines, commercial lines as well as life insurance....
Donna has been in the Independent world of Insurance for over 25 years Donna graduated from Caesar Rodney High School in 1980 Donna enjoys living her fullest life with her grandchildren, family and friends. Donna loves to swim and has...
Jennifer started her career with Carey Insurance Group in September 2020. She is one of our Account Managers in our Dover Office. Jennifer attended Old Dominion University and Virginia Commonwealth University. Jennifer's hobbies...
Commercial Lines Account Manager
Gwen is Licensed for Property & Casualty. And providing continued service to our Commercial and Farm policy holders at our Laurel, Delaware office. Gwen comes to us from the Banking industry with over 33 years’ experience.
Kaye started her career with Carey Insurance Group in July 2019. She comes to us with over 20 years experience in the Insurance industry. Kaye graduated from Georgetown Senior High in 1982 Kaye is a member of Bethel Worship Center. Her...
Commercial & Agribusiness Specialist
Monty E. Carey is the Commercial & Agribusiness Specialist for Carey Insurance Group. Monty Joined Carey Insurance on November 10, 2010. Prior to joining Carey Insurance, Monty owned his own landscaping company for approximately 8...
Prior to coming our Berlin, Maryland office she owned and operated a seasonal tourism based fishing/cruise boat in Ocean City, MD for over 30 years. Karen attended Wor-Wic Community college and studied General Business and Insurance...
Before Pursuing a career in the Insurance Industry Marie was a member of the Philadelphia Police Department for over 19 years. In 2000 Marie started her second career as a Licensed Property and Casualty, Life Agent working in...
Fiduciary Account Manager
Kim comes to us with over25 years of experience in the Insurance Industry. Prior to her career in Insurance she had over 9 years in the Banking Industry. Kim attended Wor-Wic Community College for Business Administration. She loves...
Dave started his career with Insurance in 2013 and works out of our Princess Anne, Maryland office. Prior to Dave was the Regional Director of the Maryland Farm Bureau – Eastern Shore/Southern Maryland for over 16 years. Dave...
Kim comes to us with over 33 years of Experience in the Insurance Industry and works out of our Princess Anne Office. Where she holds the position of Associate Agent /Office Manager. She is Licensed in P&C and Life & Health. Kim enjoys...
Linda joined Carey Insurance after retiring from Peninsula Insurance Company after 48 years in 2018. She is a licensed P&C agent. Linda enjoys the outdoors, yardwork and traveling to visit her family. She is a member of St. Francis de...
Sue joined Carey Insurance after retiring from Peninsula Insurance Company after 50 Years in 2018. She enjoys going to the beach, traveling, spending time with family and friends. Her passion is quilting.
Teresa started her career with Carey Insurance Group in August 2020. Teresa holds the position of Customer Service Representative and in the Princess Anne office. Teresa graduated from James M Bennett Sr. High School in 1980. Teresa...
Becky oversees operations of all 6 Carey Insurance Group locations. Becky comes to us with over 40 years of Business Management experience. Becky studied Business Management from University of South Carolina and Marketing at Wor Wic...
David J Clark Jr. is an Associate Agent for Carey Insurance Group. David specializes in Workers Compensation Insurance, as well as personal lines insurance. David joined Carey Insurance Group in 2021. Prior to Carey Insurance, David...
Kyle Fritz is an Account Executive for Carey Insurance Group. Kyle joined the team after graduating from University of Delaware in 2019 with a B.S. in Financial Planning and Wealth Management. Kyle specializes in Commercial Lines,...